Ok, I had a crack at it - not my usual game but it was fun! Apologies if it doesn't render as desired, eventhing was done in illustrator because I dont have any fancy pants programs : ) Should be fine though.
I reckon in this song and dance number Joes character would see God as a Fred Astaire/The Dude from the Big Lebowski type of fella.
Stuck to Andy's (AW Clift) design so the two leads can be visually consistent, allowing everyone to go nuts on the extras.
I'd love some oxfords on him (or cowboy boots but might be a bit cliche) and maybe a top hat - don't want to get too carried away though. Sorry my skills a a tad limited when it comes to footwear.
Also considered developing the cane into a more trident-esque version...