love it !! beautiful, kept on playing it again and again ;)
love wirrow's words and voice's tone

This was my absolute favorite from last night's show!! You do such great work!

very beautiful...

I can't help but think of this music video when I'm thinking about this project..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40G8sbl6o9c

Hi Greg, I didn't have time to sit down and watch this until now, and then it whoosh! right off the page and I forgot all about it.

I love that you edited to the beat of the voice, whereas in most cases editors will edit to the beat of the music (in this case there isn't any, beat that is). Also, I think you really understood the context of the piece, its purpose and meaning, which is something that I find really important when editing. The visuals you've chosen (and you found some great clips!) really match the mood and the subtext of wirrow's piece.

The glimmering water near the end is a really great example of one of the fantastic clips you chose...it felt to me like a echo on the audio, even though there was silence in the voice over. Perfect!

The only thing I would say that would make this so much better, is that at the end, you cut back to the glasses, and then the filmstrip. I would have left it with the clip of the sun shining through the trees and then maybe a fade to white. I felt like all of that work you did building up the mood and tone of the piece got prematurely cut off. There is enough of a sustain on the glasses to glide us into the fade, and the filmstrip (while it is a great resource) just felt out of place.

I hope you don't mind my £.02 about that, amongst all that praise. You have done a really fantastic job here and it's clear you've put a lot of effort into this, which is well worth it!

Fantastic work, Dr G. Many hearts for you <3

Really amazing.

Haunting in a beautiful way.

i have goosebumps... no doubt you constructed that "something more" in visual form. wow.

Chills man... chills.